On CSEPartnersNote BookPress ReleasesCSE Washington



 






















































about us
down to earth
environmental
resources
environment
and you
calendar
campaigns

HOME
FEEDBACK
GUIDED TOUR
PUBLICATIONS
SEARCH


Click here to go `Top'

About Us - Press Releases 



homefeedbackguided tourPublicationsSearch

PRESS RELEASE OF 11th SEPTEMBER 1998

Civil Society Expresses Solidarity with Anna Hazare
A spectrum of the NGO (Non-governmental Organisation) community and members of civil society in Delhi join Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) in expressing strong indignation over the unfortunate turn of events that led to the jail sentence of Anna Hazare. It is important to consider that Anna is among the clutch of most eminent citizens who with integrity, has dedicated his life to alleviating the community in which he has lived. Anna’s community today, is not just his village but the entire country, as his work is being replicated and encouraged in many parts of the country. Though one of India’s outstanding environmental worker, yet he has been sentenced to three months of simple imprisonment, on the charge of ‘defaming’ a controversial Maharashtra minister, Mr Babanrao Gholap.

This turn of events has severe implications for civil society, people’s movements and the work of the media, especially those raising their voice against the widespread corruption in Indian society. It also sends out a converse message to the corrupt. Social activists and those working at the village level often run into the corruption that has seeped into every sphere of our lives. A worker committed to a cause only has two options; one to fight it with the strength of conviction, and two, to become a part of ‘the system’. A person like Anna, quite naturally, chose the former. He had over the years, attempted to focus public attention onto the corrupt aspect of Indian society, at a time when there are only a few politicians against whom there are no charges of corruption.

Such is the state of affairs that even the country’s premier investigation agency, the Central Bureau of Investigation, has not yet proven a single case against any of the political figures in the much-hyped hawala scam. In a situation where the access to information is highly restricted even to the top investigative agency, it is simply not tenable for an individual to raise proof. There is no freedom in our system to access information. When there is so much secrecy involved in utilisation of public funds, how can civil society prove corruption?

In the Seymour Hersh-Morarji Desai incident when the American journalist accused Desai of being on the rolls of the CIA, Desai could not win a case of defamation against Hersh. In such instances, the malafide intent of an accusation has to be proved, as per US laws. Mr Babanrao Gholap should have been obliged to establish malice in Anna’s accusation. Booking Hazare for criminal liability, instead of civil liability, is an extreme response which would brook challenge with the higher judiciary.

The misuse of public funds along with negligible accountability enforces a conspiracy of silence on the country. There is a desperate need to expose this corruption and misuse of funds. As Prime Minister, the late Rajiv Gandhi had informed the Parliament that only 15 paise of a Rupee reached the people of the country.

The example of Anna’s work has considerable influence on the rural development policies of various state governments. Chandra Babu Naidu, chief minister (CM) of Andhra Pradesh, and Digvijay Singh, CM of Madhya Pradesh, use Anna’s work as a blueprint in development of rural areas in the state.

We fully support Anna Hazare’s cause and express solidarity with him. We also suggest that the laws which have led to his sentence, be revised. If not, no one can take up the case of corruption against public figures. Any allegation made may end in criminal liability on the part of the accuser.

Statement supported by (organisations and individuals):

  • Development Alternatives, Delhi.
  • Public Interest Research Group, Delhi.
  • Indian Social Institute, Delhi.
  • Sristhi, New Delhi.
  • Vatavaran, New Delhi.
  • Centre for Education and Communication (CEC), Delhi.
  • Toxics Link, New Delhi.
  • Greenpeace International, Delhi.
  • Delhi Forum, Delhi.
  • Centre for Science and Environment, New Delhi.
  • Kamla Chowdhry, Society for Promotion of Wastelands Development.
  • Anupam Mishra, Gandhi Peace Foundation, Delhi.
  • Ashish Kothari, Kalpavriksh, Pune.
  • Vimal, National Alliance for People’s Movements (NAPM), Delhi chapter.
  • Rajni Kothari, Delhi.
  • Bittu Sehgal, Editor - The Sanctuary.
  • Anil Bordia, Lok Jumbish Parishad, Jaipur.

If you agree with the above sentiments, please send us your comments along with your name and address.

  Warning

[ ON CSE | PARTNERS | NOTEBOOK | PRESS RELEASE | CSE WASHINGTON ]


Copyright © CSE  Centre for Science and Environment